Carry-On or Checked Bag? What’s Best for a 5–7 Day All-Inclusive Getaway

When you're heading off on a well-deserved 5–7 day all-inclusive vacation, you might think the biggest decision is beach or pool. But ask any seasoned traveler, and they'll tell you: the carry-on vs. checked bag debate is real—and it can make or break how relaxed your trip feels from takeoff to touchdown. 

As a travel advisor who's helped hundreds of clients jet off to dream destinations, from the white sands of Punta Cana to the turquoise waters of Turks and Caicos, I've seen both sides of this luggage dilemma. So today, I’m breaking down the pros and cons of each option—and helping you decide what’s best for your next all-inclusive getaway. 

The Case for Carry-On Only: Light, Quick, and Hassle-Free

There’s something freeing about skipping baggage claim and heading straight to paradise. For many travelers, carrying on is the gold standard, especially for trips under a week. 

Benefits of Traveling Carry-On:

• Faster airport exits: No waiting at the carousel.
• Less risk of lost luggage: Your bag is with you the whole time.
• Streamlined packing: Forces you to pack only what you truly need.
• Easier hotel check-in: No need to wait for bags to be delivered to your room. 

If your all-inclusive is only 5–7 days and you don’t plan to do much outside the resort, a carry-on might be all you need. Pack a couple of swimsuits, a beach cover-up, evening outfits for dinners, and versatile shoes—and you’re golden. 

Pro Tip: Use the 3-3-3 Rule for effortless capsule packing:

• 3 tops
• 3 bottoms
• 3 pairs of shoes (beach sandals, comfy day shoes, dressy dinner pair) 

And don’t forget to roll your clothes and use packing cubes to maximize space.  “I always recommend the compression packing cubes to my clients, not only do they organize your clothing – they also maximize on space.  That one extra zipper makes such a big difference.” – Tina Moczynski, All-Inclusive Specialist and Travel Advisor, Shores And More Travel. 

The Case for Checked Luggage: Room to Breathe (and Pack More Options)

On the flip side, checking a bag offers convenience in a different way—especially for travelers who like outfit variety or are bringing special gear. 

Benefits of Checking a Bag:

• More wardrobe flexibility: Great if your resort has themed nights or upscale restaurants with dress codes.
• Room for extras: Pack full-sized toiletries, snorkel gear, or your favorite beach towel.
• Stress-free airport boarding: No need to fight for overhead bin space.
• Souvenir space: Leave room for goodies to bring home without worrying about weight limits. 

While it does come with the risk of delays or loss, many travelers find the space and simplicity worth it—especially if they’re not doing multiple stops or tight connections. 

Choosing Based on Destination & Trip Type

The best choice often depends on where you’re going and how you’re traveling. 

• Nonstop flights? Checked luggage is less risky.
• Multiple layovers? Carry-on is safer and faster.
• Luxury resort with formal dining? Checked bag gives you more wardrobe flexibility.
• Adults-only beachfront getaway? You can probably keep it simple with a carry-on. 

As a travel advisor, I help my clients weigh these decisions based on their unique trip. I consider not just the destination, but the resort type, the events planned, weather conditions, and even your personality type. (Yes, the over-packers and last-minute throwers—we see you and we love you!) 

Considerations for 2025 Travel

Travel trends in 2025 continue to lean toward efficiency and personalization. Airlines are enforcing stricter carry-on size policies, and checked baggage fees vary wildly by carrier. 

Additionally, global data still shows a slightly higher rate of lost or delayed luggage during peak travel months, especially in summer and winter holidays. This means if you do check a bag, it’s more important than ever to pack smart in your personal item—including essentials like: 

• A change of clothes
• Swimwear
• Travel documents
• Medications
• Chargers
• Valuables 

With proper planning, even a delayed bag won’t derail your trip. 

Travel Advisor Insight: It’s Not Just About the Bag

Whether you check a bag or carry on, the real key to vacation peace-of-mind lies in how well your trip is planned. Timing your flights to maximize your time on the ground, picking resorts that match your vibe (and your wardrobe!), and prepping for the “what-ifs” is where I come in. 

As your travel advisor, I don't just help you pick a destination—I help you prepare like a pro, travel like a VIP, and come home relaxed, not regretful. 

Your Vacation, Your Way—Let’s Get Planning

Ready to trade your packing stress for a perfectly planned 5–7 day all-inclusive escape? 
Contact me today to start planning your next adventure!

And if you're not quite ready to book just yet, that’s okay too! 
Join my Live It List Club —where you’ll receive travel tips, destination inspiration, and exclusive content delivered straight to your inbox. It’s the first step toward a getaway that fits your life, your style, and your bucket list.